3.13.2011

Review: Anna and the French Kiss

I woke up today thinking, holy smoley, I need to write a blog post. What happened to my New Year's Resolution to post nearly daily? What a blogging fail.

I think life is moving too quickly for me (whaaa? I'm going to graduate from high school soon? I'm going to college?!), but also horrifically slowly (why do the days drag by slower than snails?).

I really should blog to fill that time up.

Anyways, a few weeks ago I was hyperventilating over Anna and the French Kiss. Reviews were uniformly glorious. I hopped to Book Depository, ordered, and it soon showed up on my door step, wrapped and bundled up. I read it last week.

Which brings me to this present day. Lately I've been feeling a bit deflated because, *drum roll* I gave up chocolate for lent. WHY DID I DO THIS TO MYSELF HOW COULD I GIVE UP MY TITULAR LOVE? NOOO000oooo!!!. So far, this has NOT been going well. *is in chocolate withdrawal*

*rolls around in pain and heartache*

*soul cries out*

Ahem.

Review time.

Book Summary:

Anna is looking forward to her senior year in Atlanta, where she has a great job, a loyal best friend, and a crush on the verge of becoming more. Which is why she is less than thrilled about being shipped off to boarding school in Paris—until she meets Étienne St. Claire: perfect, Parisian (and English and American, which makes for a swoon-worthy accent), and utterly irresistible. The only problem is that he's taken, and Anna might be, too, if anything comes of her almost-relationship back home.

As winter melts into spring, will a year of romantic near-misses end with the French kiss Anna—and readers—have long awaited?

My Opinion:

Anna and the French Kiss starts out slow. In particular, the first three chapters drag by at a glacial pace, as the narrator busies herself with filling in backstory. However, the novel soon picks up speed, and by the end manages to overcome most of its flaws and standout as one of YA's funnest romance reads of the year.

I am jealous of Anna. Oh, how I wish that my parents had packed me off to boarding school in history-soaked Paris, bakery goods and beautiful architecture everywhere, the ambiance of another country to fill my days. An experience like that would have quite honestly made my life, so at first I could not relate to the homesickness and resentful moping Anna felt as she acclimated to her new environment. Of course, many teenage girls would feel the same way as her and all in all, Anna is a pretty realistic character, which is the most important thing. I appreciated that she had a real passion--film--in her life, and ambitions to become something when she was older. I appreciated that her dialogue wasn't stilted or forced, that she thought like a teenage girl, that she had insecurities and flaws that added to her characterization. Above all, I found her relatable and likable, if a bit humdrum.

I'm not so sure about the other characters though. I know that Etienne is supposed to the ultimate love interest, but I didn't really care for him. He seemed a little too, I don't know, perfect. How many teenage boys exist like him? I really think they're a rare, if not extinct, breed. But I guess a suspension of belief on my part is needed, and the fact that he seems like a relatively caring, sweet person really negates a lot of the realism problems. The thing is, though, that as the story progressed, and Anna fell more and more in love with him, to the point of blind devotion, I couldn't help but wonder how unreliable Anna is with her observations of him. We're presented with this perfect semblance of a teenage guy: nice hair, an English accent, extremely intelligent, caring. Yet, his actions are anything but. If you pause and really think about him objectively-- fuzzy descriptions aside-- he's actually quite a jerk. He strings Anna along (a later explanation of continuous misunderstandings didn't really convince me) for much of the book. He flirts with other girls. He basically is leading Anna on, while he has a serious girlfriend that he won't break up with. I have to ask, isn't that cheating? Isn't breaking up with the girl you're not in love with anymore the decent thing to do before you start gallivanting around town?

I don't know, that just strikes me as a horrid thing to do, whatever Anna tells me.

This book posed a few interesting questions for me as a reader. Am I just not a romance reader, since I often find such issues with the idealized guy? Am I just cynical? Is the devotion Anna has in anyway similar to the devotion paranormal main characters have for their immortal boyfriends that I find so troubling? How do you differentiate between love and obsession?

I think I mostly got the impression of love out of Anna and the French Kiss. What really saved the book was the gradual development of the relationship, the fact that they were friends first, that Anna helps Etienne through a hard time because she cares about him, not because he's got a pretty face. I think what separates this book from most YA romance is the fact that the relationship is mostly based on the two's actions for each other, not how hot or physically attracted they are to each other.

And that makes all the difference.

The one thing I thought was unrealistic: the college application process described. The timing was way off for when Anna got her acceptances, unless she got early notification, and it really wasn't explained at all, or explained vaguely. I found it strange that Anna kinda underhandedly decided about the whole thing without telling the reader about it. I mean, if you're going to move from Paris across to the other side of the country that you're normally from, I think that'd factor into your thoughts during senior year. At least a little bit, I'd hope.

Ultimately, as much as a I complain, I can't deny that I had a wonderful time reading the book, and was caught up in the romance and most of all, her experience in Paris. Perkins has a gift for making her main character really develop, though many of the secondary characters did not come to life and were not as well-formed as Anna. I loved that Anna grew out of her hermitly ways and really blossomed. It was quite a nice thing to read about, and the relationship portrayed was endlessly complicated and interesting.

My Rating: 8.25/10. A good book, overall. I appreciated the many barbs against Nicholas Sparks types (ie Anna's Dad), too.
ETA: I think most readers will enjoy it more than I did, so yes, I do recommend it :)

Comments (14)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I freaking loved this book. And actually, I thought Etienne was delightfully average. He isn't Mr. Perfecty Perfect like a certain sexy vampire love interest. He reminded me of Alex Day from YouTube, who isn't really a looker xD
2 replies · active 733 weeks ago
This! So much this! :D
My recent post Friday Fill-Ins 1
Except I've never seen Alex Day... but the delightfully average part I definitely agree with.
My recent post Friday Fill-Ins 1
A very insightful review. This is the first that is mixed and critical. So far all I have read are gushing reviews, so this one makes me take a step back and re-think if this one is in fact for me. I think I will end up giving it a go since it sounds like such a charming read. Thanks for being honest! :)
1 reply · active 733 weeks ago
Yes, I'd recommend it.

I just have trouble turning my critical brain off while reading, I think you'd enjoy this book :)
@Becca:

I'm glad that you loved the book so much. :)

In my opinion, Etienne was anything but average. I've never met a teenage guy who has a combination of a British accent, an intellectual interest in history and learning, nice hair, and a caring and sensitive nature.

Of course, if you flipped that and applied those same characteristics to teenage girls, I've never met one of those either.

They exist, but in my experience, they're far from the norm.
Why hello, fellow tortured soul!
oh, chocolate...*sigh*
Despite my complaints, I really did enjoy AFK. Maybe push it up a few spots? :)
Anna and The French Kiss? *swoon* I just loved that book!
What I liked about Etienne is that he was realistic. He's mixed up, making stupid decisions, and yea, leading girls on. That doesn't make him a good boyfriend, but it does make him a neat character to read. Anna also isn't perfect. I thought she was whiny at some points. But that's what I liked about them, and the book.

And I LOVED the descriptions of Paris. I so want to go now, just to eat the bread! :D
My recent post Friday Fill-Ins 1
Hi,

I'm Kate Evangelista, author of Taste, and I just wanted to take this time to introduce myself. If you have the time, please stop by The Coffee Bar by using the link below:
http://kateevangelistanovels.blogspot.com/

I hope to see you there.

Sincerely,
Kate
I'm a little sad that you didn't love it intensely as I did BUT I appreciate your honesty. Personally, I don't think Anna's devotion is similar to the devotion that many paranormal heronies have since like you said, Anna & St. Clair gradually get to know each other, they see each other's faults and they STILL care for one another despite the fact that they both mess up. I think that's what seperates them from the realm of blind obsession/devotion that some characters in the paranormal genre are in. They genuinely appreciate each other, LIKE each other and then fall in love with each other (and there's no oncoming apocalypse or anything). I've read a bunch of paranormal/supernatural things and usually the guy in the books have no faults at all-which is unrealistic but whatevs, it's in a book. I can pretend for a while, hah.
My recent post Wither book trailer!
Yeah, I agree with the whole Etienne being too perfect, thing. I actually liked that he was a bit of a jerk re the whole Ellie thing, humanised him a little. But I did like the way she developed the romance, and sometimes a little wish fulfillment when reading can be awesome.

Also, Stephanie Perkins' voice and dialogue? So spot on :D
My recent post Crits for Water
I still haven't read this, but really want to. Great review!
My recent post Waiting On Wednesday- Pure

Post a new comment

Comments by